Esoteric Dissertations from a One-Track Mind

June 12, 2008

American Nerd: A Review

Filed under: books, culture, history — Tags: , — codesmithy @ 8:53 am

I finished up reading “American Nerd: The Story of My People” by Benjamin Nugent.  I first heard about book when Rachel Maddow interviewed the author on radio show.  The book was a good example of intellectual candy.  It was an enjoyable read.  There are a few interesting tidbits here and there.  Although, on the whole, it didn’t feel very nutritious.

The book is, perhaps unsurprisingly, about nerds.  What are nerds?  What is perception of nerds in the society?  How did nerds come to be viewed this way?  What does a nerd hope and dream about that may be different from other people?

To begin with, Nugent traces through some threads of anti-intellectualism in America.  Perhaps it shouldn’t be surprising that American anti-intellectualism appears to have its roots tied indirectly to racism and xenophobic fears.  The prototypical nerd is based off of a hard-working, immigrant Jews and Asians, so called “grinds” or “greasy grinds,” who perceived their best chance at advancement in society as being linked to education.  It is actually a testimony to the remarkable success of the immigrants that institutions within the society had to take measures to move the goal posts.  Intellectual achievement could no longer be the determining factor, other characteristics like nobility and hardiness were lauded.  Like any remarkably successful group that challenges existing power, the “grinds” were consequently demonized.

Nugent looks at some of the popular culture portrayals of nerds and nerd culture as well, focusing on the escapism and rule-based aspects, including hyper-whiteness traits, such as mispronouncing words that had obviously only been read, and not spoken aloud to a knowledgeable audience.

Nugent progresses to his personal life, examines some people he grew up with and looked at why they embraced nerdiness.

Nugent mentions Revenge of the Nerds multiple times.  So, I am sort of surprised he didn’t incorporate the main theme of that movie into the book.  Nearly everyone struggles with trying to be accepted, especially in middle school and high school.  Everyone has dramas and crises going on in their life at any given moment.  Nerds are a group that deals with that alienation in a particular way, and maybe that is worth exploring, but it behooves you to mention that the problem isn’t unique to just nerds.  The problem faces everyone.  Everyone feels alienated at one time or another.  This is the prime Nixonian political calculation, there are always a lot more losers than winners.  If you get the losers to band together, you can just ride their antipathy towards the perceived winners to power.

It is hard to bemoan the plight of being a nerd.  Even the self-described ones such as Nugent is doing so well he is getting books published.  His best friend Kenneth was a video game testing lead/program manager.   Self-loathing is a problem, but the big problem with that there is no measure of perspective.  Maybe high school sucks and girls don’t like you.  Is that worse than getting your arm blown off by a bomblet in Cambodia or Laos, or being deformed by Agent Orange in Vietnam?  Intelligence is a gift, even if you find yourself alienated, or depressed.  Maybe one would never miss it, but it doesn’t mean humanity wouldn’t be poorer from the difference.

Advertisements

2 Comments »

  1. You wrote: “Is that worse than getting your arm blown off by a bomblet in Cambodia or Laos, or being deformed by Agent Orange in Vietnam?”

    Why are you, like so many countless people, always going for the most extreme comparisons, in order to win a point? Is that somehow the equivalent of “having an army” behind you to back you up?

    Whatever — stop it. Just stop it.

    Comment by Paul Martin — July 13, 2008 @ 9:11 pm

  2. Hi Paul,

    The reason why I brought up cluster munitions was because it was on my mind when I wrote the post.

    https://codesmithy.wordpress.com/2008/06/02/111-countries-agree-to-ban-cluster-munitions/

    And so was Monsanto
    https://codesmithy.wordpress.com/2008/04/15/vanity-fair-monsantos-harvest-of-fear/

    Basically, our government has turned its back on its moral duty. The results will be predictable. One day, kids, who knows how many, are going to get a limb blown off because of our government’s policy. If we could muster 1/10 th the moral outrage over that as opposed to an iPhone price drop, how different would the world be? The difference is being wholly consumed with your own life, compared to actually giving a shit about someone else’s half-way around the world.

    I don’t consider it meaningless hand-wringing, like bemoaning the atrocities of Ghengis Khan. There are actions the United States government could take today that would prevent untold suffering in the future. It isn’t going to happen on its own, people are going to have to press the government to make it happen.

    Maybe you feel that I brought it up too casually and thereby trivialized it. My goal was to remind people of the tragedies of the past to keep some perspective, and they are carefully chosen, because there are definite actions our government could take today to prevent these horrible events from taking place in the future.

    If you are upset about alienation in high-school, how about sympathizing with an Iraqi family that is getting blown up today because of cluster munitions? There are more important things in life than the circumstances of your own condition. In a global view, we actually have it pretty good in the U.S. So how about we try stopping our government and corporations from making the world a shitty place to be for other people? This isn’t about people starving in some remote corner of the world, this is about people we purposefully blew up, terrorized and poisoned, a legacy we like to forget but the victims are reminded of every day.

    Whatever — stop it. Just stop it.

    No. If you don’t like what I have to say, go someplace else.

    Comment by codesmithy — July 14, 2008 @ 6:02 am


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: